Motor Finance Commission Disclosure: What UK Car Dealers Must Do After the Supreme Court Ruling

An FCA compliance guide for dealership principals, F&I managers and compliance teams
Motor finance commission disclosure is no longer a question of whether a dealership has included the right sentence in its paperwork. The more important question is whether customers receive clear, timely information about how the dealer is remunerated — and whether the dealership can demonstrate that its finance sales process supports informed decisions.
The Supreme Court's August 2025 ruling changed the legal position on motor finance commissions. The FCA subsequently introduced a motor finance redress scheme in March 2026, parts of which are now suspended following legal challenges. In November 2026, the regulator also published expectations for lenders making voluntary settlement offers while those challenges continue.
For dealerships, the immediate priority is to keep current F&I sales compliant, preserve historical records and work effectively with lenders and regulatory principals.
The key points are:
Commission arrangements are not inherently unlawful. However, applicable FCA disclosure requirements remain in force.
Credit brokers must make prescribed disclosures about commission, fees and other remuneration where the conditions in FCA rules are met.
Customers who request the amount of commission must be given the amount, or likely amount where the precise figure is not known, in good time before entering the relevant regulated agreement.
The Consumer Duty requires in-scope firms to consider whether their communications genuinely support customer understanding.
The historic motor finance redress scheme is partially suspended, not cancelled. Relevant obligations remain in force, including requirements concerning broker information.
Dealerships should review the effectiveness of their controls rather than relying solely on signed disclosure documents.
This guide explains the current position and how to translate it into practical dealership procedures.
1. What did the Supreme Court decide about motor finance commission?
On 1 August 2025, the Supreme Court delivered its judgment in the joined cases of Hopcraft v Close Brothers, Johnson v FirstRand and Wrench v FirstRand — reported as [2025] UKSC 33.
The Court substantially overturned the October 2024 Court of Appeal judgment.
In the typical dealer–customer–lender arrangements considered, the Supreme Court concluded that the motor dealers did not owe the fiduciary duties alleged by the customers. Consequently, the claims based on bribery and dishonest assistance did not succeed.
That was an important development for the motor finance industry.
However, it did not mean that undisclosed commission was automatically lawful.
Why the Johnson case still matters
The Supreme Court found that the relationship between Mr Johnson and his lender was unfair under section 140A of the Consumer Credit Act 1974.
Relevant circumstances included:
The size of the commission.
The inadequate disclosure of that commission.
The concealment of a commercial arrangement between the dealer and lender.
The decision illustrates why commission disputes cannot be assessed by considering disclosure wording in isolation. The overall circumstances of the transaction matter.
For dealers, the practical lesson is straightforward: a finance arrangement may create legal and regulatory risk even where the dealership has not breached a general fiduciary duty.
The judgment does not establish that every undisclosed commission produces an unfair relationship, nor does it impose a universal requirement for written informed consent to every commission payment.
Dealers should avoid relying on summaries of the superseded Court of Appeal decision when updating their current policies.
Primary source: UK Supreme Court judgment, 1 August 2025 — [2025] UKSC 33.
2. What are the FCA's current commission disclosure rules?
The principal regulatory requirements are contained in CONC 4.5, the commission provisions of the FCA's Consumer Credit sourcebook.
The precise application depends on the regulated activity and agreement involved. Dealerships undertaking credit broking should establish which rules apply to their activities, including any relevant appointed representative arrangements.
Disclosing the existence and nature of commission
Under CONC 4.5.3R, a credit broker must prominently disclose the existence and nature of commission, fees or other remuneration payable by a lender, owner or third party where its existence or amount could actually or potentially:
Affect the broker's impartiality when recommending an agreement; or
Have a material impact on the customer's decision to enter into the agreement.
This is a binding FCA rule.
The disclosure must be made in good time before the customer enters into the agreement.
Under CONC 4.5.3AR, where disclosure is required under CONC 4.5.3R, the broker must also explain, at the same time and with equal prominence, how the existence and nature of the remuneration may affect the amounts payable by the customer.
The FCA's accompanying guidance in CONC 4.5.3BG addresses circumstances including variable remuneration and differences between products or lenders.
For a dealership operating a lender panel, these provisions warrant particular attention where commission arrangements differ between available finance products.
Does every dealer have to disclose the exact commission amount?
The distinction between the existence, nature and amount of commission is important.
CONC 4.5.4R requires a credit broker, at the customer's request, to disclose the amount of commission, fee or other remuneration — or its likely amount if the precise amount is unknown — in good time before entry into the relevant regulated credit or consumer hire agreement.
The rule does not, by itself, impose a universal requirement to provide the exact monetary commission amount proactively on every transaction.
However, that is not the end of the regulatory assessment.
Under the Consumer Duty, an in-scope firm must consider whether the information it provides enables customers to make effective, timely and informed decisions. Depending on the circumstances, providing more detail than the express minimum in CONC may be appropriate.
The FCA has identified prominent, personalised commission information as an approach that can support customer understanding.
Dealerships should therefore distinguish between:
The binding minimum: What the applicable CONC rules expressly require.
The wider regulatory obligation: What is necessary to deliver the applicable Consumer Duty outcomes.
A proportionate good-practice approach: Providing clear commission information, potentially including the monetary amount and calculation method, at an appropriate stage without waiting for a customer to ask.
The chosen approach should be assessed against the dealership's actual finance arrangements, customers and distribution model.
Are discretionary commission arrangements still permitted?
No. The FCA prohibited discretionary commission arrangements of the type defined in its rules from 28 January 2021.
Under CONC 4.5.6R, lenders and credit brokers must not enter into, maintain or rely upon prohibited discretionary commission arrangements.
These were arrangements under which brokers had discretion over the price of credit and their commission was affected by that discretion.
The prohibition does not mean that all lender-paid commission is banned.
A fixed-fee or other non-discretionary commission arrangement may be permitted, but it remains subject to applicable disclosure requirements and wider conduct obligations.
Primary source: FCA Handbook — CONC 4.5: Commissions.
3. Why commission disclosure must be part of the finance conversation
One of the most significant operational risks is treating commission disclosure as a document-production exercise.
Consider a typical dealership transaction.
A customer agrees on a vehicle price, discusses monthly affordability, selects a finance product and prepares to sign the agreement. Immediately before signature, the sales executive presents a disclosure document containing a paragraph about commission.
The customer signs.
The dealership has evidence that the document was presented and acknowledged. But can it demonstrate that the customer had sufficient opportunity to consider the information and ask questions?
That distinction matters.
The FCA's published expectations on communicating with motor finance customers explain that information provided only immediately before signing may be too late to support an informed decision.
The regulator has also highlighted the importance of accessible language, prominent information and appropriate testing of customer understanding.
What does the Consumer Duty require?
For activities within its scope, the Consumer Duty includes a requirement to act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers.
The consumer understanding outcome is particularly relevant to commission disclosure.
A dealership should consider whether customers can understand:
That the dealership acts as a credit broker, rather than necessarily as the lender.
Whether the dealership receives remuneration connected with arranging finance.
The nature of that remuneration.
Whether commission arrangements may influence the selection or presentation of finance products.
Whether the dealership works with a limited lender panel or has material commercial ties.
How remuneration may affect what the customer pays.
The Consumer Duty is not retrospective. It applies to ongoing actions relating to open products and services from 31 July 2023 and closed products and services from 31 July 2024, subject to its scope and application provisions.
It should not be presented as a new legal basis for judging all historic conduct before those dates.
A better approach to timing
A sensible dealership process introduces relevant information while the customer is considering finance, not merely at the final signature stage.
For example:
At the initial finance discussion: Explain the dealership's role as a broker, the relevant lender arrangements and how the business may be remunerated.
When presenting a particular finance option: Provide the applicable commission information and explain any relevant relationship between remuneration and the finance costs.
Before the agreement is entered into: Confirm that the required information has been provided, deal with questions and respond to any request for the amount of commission.
These are suggested operational control points, not a mandatory three-stage sequence prescribed by the FCA.
The objective is to give the customer a genuine opportunity to use the information.
Primary source: FCA — Communicating with motor finance customers about commission.
4. Three dealership scenarios that expose common weaknesses
Scenario A: The dealer operates a panel with different commission arrangements
An independent dealer has access to three lenders.
Two pay fixed commissions, while the third uses a different remuneration structure. A customer may qualify for more than one finance product.
The F&I executive presents one lender's agreement but cannot explain whether remuneration differs between the available options.
The risk: The customer may not understand the nature of the broker's financial incentives, and the dealership may struggle to demonstrate that its product presentation is appropriately controlled.
A proportionate response: Review the commission arrangements across the lender panel, document relevant differences, establish suitable customer disclosures and monitor whether finance recommendations are being influenced by remuneration rather than customer circumstances.
The dealership should also review the FCA guidance in CONC 4.5.3BG concerning variable remuneration across agreements.
Scenario B: A franchised dealer has a preferred finance partner
A franchised dealer tells customers that it can search a panel of lenders.
However, its contractual arrangements give one lender a right of first refusal.
The problem is not necessarily the existence of the commercial relationship. It is whether the dealership's description of its finance offering accurately reflects the arrangements in place.
The risk: Customers could receive a misleading impression of the dealer's independence or the choice available to them.
A proportionate response: Review lender contracts, preferred-partner arrangements, first-refusal rights and customer-facing statements together. Check that sales scripts, websites and finance documentation do not contradict the underlying commercial arrangements.
The Supreme Court's findings in Johnson make this a particularly important area for management review.
Scenario C: The customer completes the finance journey remotely
A customer reserves a vehicle online and completes the finance process from home.
Commission information is included within a digital document pack, but the customer receives no meaningful explanation of it.
The risk: A digital acknowledgement may demonstrate that a document was delivered, but it does not necessarily establish that the information was clear, sufficiently prominent or understood.
A proportionate response: Present key disclosures visibly within the digital journey, allow appropriate time for review, provide a route for questions and retain evidence of the process followed.
Where a customer needs an alternative communication method, the process should accommodate that need.
The same principles apply whether the customer is in the showroom, on the telephone or completing the transaction online.
5. What does the FCA's motor finance redress scheme mean for dealers?
On 30 March 2026, the FCA published PS26/3, confirming an industry-wide motor finance consumer redress scheme.
The scheme concerns eligible historic motor finance agreements entered into between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024, inclusive, where the applicable scheme conditions are met.
It comprises separate arrangements for agreements entered into:
From 6 April 2007 to 31 March 2014.
From 1 April 2014 to 1 November 2024.
It is important not to confuse the scheme's historical scope with the rules applying to finance transactions being arranged today.
The scheme is partially suspended
Following legal challenges, the Upper Tribunal ordered a partial suspension of the scheme in July 2026.
As at 16 November 2026, the FCA confirms that the challenges are scheduled to be heard between 16 February and 3 March 2027.
The outcome is uncertain.
The partial suspension does not remove every requirement under the scheme. The FCA continues to require firms to prepare, progress relevant complaints and comply with provisions that remain in force.
Lenders do not currently have to calculate or pay redress under the suspended scheme provisions while the legal process continues.
Some decisions and communications are still required under the retained rules.
Dealerships should therefore avoid telling customers that the scheme has been cancelled, that every complaint is frozen, or that compensation is guaranteed.
Why brokers need to prepare now
Although the scheme is primarily administered by lenders and other persons responsible under its rules, dealers acting as credit brokers may hold essential historical information.
This may include:
The commission arrangement applicable to a particular transaction.
Commission schedules, invoices and payment records.
Lender agreements and evidence of contractual ties.
Historic customer disclosure documents.
Records of sales communications.
Finance proposals and agreement information.
Records identifying the relevant dealer entity, branch or intermediary.
The FCA's retained requirements include obligations for brokers to provide relevant documents or information requested by lenders, or confirm that the information is not held, within one month of a relevant request.
The FCA's October 2026 further-information document also explains the lender's follow-up process where the broker does not respond fully.
A practical management question is whether your dealership could retrieve a 2018 finance file, identify the applicable commission arrangement and respond accurately to a lender's information request without an extensive manual investigation.
Where records are missing, the business should document its search, avoid creating retrospective evidence and communicate accurately with the requesting lender or principal.
It is also important to distinguish commission that was payable under an arrangement from commission that was ultimately paid. The FCA has clarified that the existence of a commission arrangement may be relevant to scheme scope even where no payment was ultimately received.
Primary sources:
6. What changed in November 2026 on voluntary settlement offers?
On 3 November 2026, the FCA published expectations for lenders considering voluntary settlement offers while the scheme is partially suspended. The relevant FCA guidance page was subsequently updated on 12 November 2026.
The FCA supports lenders making offers where consumers receive no less than the maximum redress available under the current scheme methodology, including applicable adjustments and caps.
The regulator expects communications accompanying these offers to explain the consumer's options and the consequences of accepting a full and final settlement.
Its published expectations include:
Making clear that the FCA has not reviewed or approved the individual offer.
Giving consumers at least one month to respond.
Explaining that consumers may accept now or await the legal challenge's outcome.
Explaining that the scheme may change or cease to operate, potentially affecting the amount otherwise payable.
Explaining the effect of a full and final settlement on the relevant complaint.
Providing appropriate information about the basis and calculation of redress.
Addressing the treatment of complaints containing both scheme and non-scheme issues.
These are the FCA's published expectations for relevant voluntary settlement communications; they should not be confused with an obligation on every dealership to make compensation offers.
What should a dealer do if a customer asks about an offer?
Dealership staff should avoid speculating about eligibility, the eventual outcome of litigation or whether an individual should accept an offer.
The appropriate response is to direct the customer to the relevant lender and official FCA information, while following the dealership's complaint-handling and escalation procedures.
Where a customer raises a separate issue — such as affordability, GAP insurance or the dealership's conduct — that issue should be identified and routed appropriately rather than automatically treated as part of the commission redress scheme.
A dealership should not negotiate or issue a purported full and final settlement on behalf of a lender without the necessary authority, procedures and legal review.
Primary source: FCA — Motor finance scheme: settlement offers.
7. Who is responsible: dealer, lender, AR, IAR or principal firm?
Responsibility depends on the activity performed, the regulatory permissions held, the applicable rules and the contractual arrangements.
It is not sufficient to describe every dealership as having identical FCA obligations.
Directly authorised dealers
A directly authorised dealership carrying on regulated credit broking is responsible for meeting the requirements applicable to its activities and permissions.
This includes relevant CONC requirements and, where applicable, the Consumer Duty.
A dealership with limited permission is not automatically exempt from commission disclosure requirements. Firms should check the scope of their permissions and the rules applying to the activities they perform.
Appointed representatives
An appointed representative operates within the scope of its appointment by an authorised principal.
The principal has regulatory responsibility for the regulated activities for which it has accepted responsibility, including appropriate oversight of its representatives.
The dealership must operate within the agreed scope and the principal's applicable controls.
The fact that a principal provides oversight does not make accurate customer communications, staff conduct or record keeping unimportant at dealership level.
Introducer appointed representatives
An introducer appointed representative has a narrower permitted scope.
Under the FCA's appointed representative framework, IAR activity is limited to specified introductions and distribution of relevant non-real-time financial promotions.
An IAR must not assume that it can conduct the full finance sales process simply because it is part of a principal's network.
The principal should establish which activities the IAR may undertake, who provides the relevant customer information and how compliance is monitored.
Lenders
Lenders have their own regulatory responsibilities.
These include applicable lending and Consumer Duty requirements, relevant oversight of broker distribution arrangements and obligations under the motor finance redress scheme.
The scheme does not transfer the lender's core responsibility for administering relevant redress decisions to every dealership that introduced the business.
Insurance distribution
Motor finance commission rules should not be automatically applied to GAP insurance, warranties or other insurance distribution activities.
Those activities may be subject to separate requirements, including ICOBS and applicable product governance rules.
A dealership conducting both credit broking and insurance distribution needs controls appropriate to each activity.
Primary sources:
8. How should a dealership improve its commission disclosure process?
The strongest approach is to design a process that works during a busy sales day, not just in a compliance manual.
Step 1: Map every material remuneration arrangement
Review lender contracts and identify the commission structures used.
Consider fixed fees, variable arrangements, volume-related incentives and other relevant remuneration.
Identify which payments relate to credit broking and which relate to other commercial activities.
Do not assume that a payment's accounting description determines its regulatory treatment.
Step 2: Check lender relationships and panel descriptions
Confirm whether the dealership uses a genuinely open panel, a restricted panel, preferred lenders or contractual first-refusal arrangements.
Compare the contractual position with what customers are told.
Correct inaccurate or potentially misleading descriptions.
Step 3: Review customer disclosures
Assess the wording against CONC 4.5 and the applicable Consumer Duty requirements.
Check that disclosures explain the nature of remuneration and, where required, its possible effect on customer payments.
Establish a reliable process for responding to requests for commission amounts.
Step 4: Put disclosures at meaningful points in the journey
Review when customers receive the information.
Avoid a process in which important commission information first appears as an obscure paragraph immediately before signature.
The objective is to provide sufficient time for consideration and questions.
Step 5: Train staff to explain, not merely present
F&I staff should understand the dealership's commission model and lender relationships.
Training should cover how to answer common questions without speculation or misleading reassurance.
Managers should periodically assess whether staff can explain the arrangements accurately.
Step 6: Retain reliable transaction evidence
Establish proportionate records of the information provided, the relevant versions of documents, customer requests and the handling of exceptions.
A signed acknowledgement is useful evidence of receipt, but should not automatically be treated as proof of understanding.
Record retention arrangements should reflect applicable legal obligations, legitimate operational needs and data protection requirements.
Step 7: Monitor actual customer outcomes
Management information should identify patterns requiring investigation.
Useful indicators include:
Disclosure exceptions and missing records.
Requests for commission amounts.
Customer questions and misunderstandings.
Differences in finance selection across lenders.
Complaints concerning commission or finance presentation.
Relevant outcomes for customers requiring additional support.
Results of file reviews, customer feedback and staff assessments.
These are suggested monitoring measures, not a prescribed FCA reporting template.
Step 8: Review historic information readiness separately
Create a controlled process for receiving lender information requests, locating historical records and recording responses.
Nominate responsible staff, establish escalation arrangements and monitor outstanding requests.
This workstream should sit alongside — rather than replace — controls for current finance sales.
9. Five mistakes dealership management should challenge
1. Assuming the Supreme Court made undisclosed commission acceptable.
The judgment rejected the general fiduciary-duty arguments in the cases considered, but the unfair-relationship provisions and FCA conduct rules remain relevant.
2. Believing a signature settles every disclosure question.
A signature may show that information was acknowledged. It does not necessarily establish that the communication was timely, sufficiently prominent or understood.
3. Using generic wording without considering actual commission arrangements.
A standard disclosure should accurately reflect the dealership's remuneration model and the information required for the particular customer journey.
4. Describing a preferred lender arrangement as an unrestricted search of the market.
Customer-facing descriptions should be consistent with the dealer's actual lender relationships.
5. Treating historic redress preparation as solely the lender's problem.
Lenders may depend on dealer-held records. Brokers have relevant obligations under the retained scheme rules.
These weaknesses are often the result of disconnected processes rather than deliberate misconduct. That makes management oversight, training and periodic testing especially important.
10. Motor finance commission disclosure: management checklist
A dealer principal or compliance director should be able to obtain clear answers to the following questions.
Do we know which regulated credit broking activities each dealership entity undertakes?
Have we mapped our current lender panel, commercial ties and remuneration arrangements?
Are commission disclosures accurate, prominent and provided at an appropriate stage?
Do our disclosures address how remuneration may affect customer payments where required?
Can staff provide the amount or likely amount of commission when a customer requests it?
Are our sales teams trained to explain commission and lender relationships in plain English?
Do our digital, telephone and showroom processes provide consistent information?
Can we identify and support customers who need additional time or alternative communications?
Do our records demonstrate what was communicated, when and through which channel?
Do we test customer understanding and investigate recurring weaknesses?
Can we locate historic commission and disclosure records when lenders request them?
Have we confirmed who handles complaints, lender requests and escalations under our authorisation or AR/IAR arrangements?
A useful follow-up is to ask management to demonstrate these controls using a sample of completed transactions rather than relying exclusively on written policy assurances.
11. Frequently asked questions
Do car dealers still have to disclose finance commission after the Supreme Court ruling?
Yes, where the applicable FCA rules require disclosure. The Supreme Court's August 2025 judgment did not remove the commission disclosure requirements in CONC 4.5 or the relevant Consumer Duty obligations.
Must a dealer disclose the exact amount of commission on every finance agreement?
CONC 4.5.4R requires disclosure of the amount, or likely amount if the precise figure is unknown, when the customer requests it in the circumstances covered by the rule. It is not a blanket requirement for proactive exact-amount disclosure on every transaction. However, wider consumer understanding obligations may justify providing more detailed information.
Are fixed motor finance commissions legal?
Fixed commissions are not inherently prohibited. The FCA's 2021 ban concerns defined discretionary commission arrangements. Other remuneration models remain subject to applicable disclosure, conduct and consumer protection requirements.
Does the FCA's motor finance compensation scheme apply to finance arranged today?
The March 2026 scheme concerns eligible historic agreements entered into between 6 April 2007 and 1 November 2024. Current transactions remain subject to the applicable law and FCA rules, but they do not fall within that historical date range.
Is the motor finance redress scheme cancelled?
No. As at 16 November 2026, the scheme is partially suspended following legal challenges. The Upper Tribunal hearing is scheduled for 16 February to 3 March 2027. Some requirements remain in force, and the eventual outcome is uncertain.
Can an appointed representative rely entirely on its principal for commission disclosure?
No dealership should assume that principal oversight removes the need for appropriate conduct and controls in its own sales operation. The principal is responsible for the regulated activities covered by the appointment, but the representative must operate within its permitted scope and follow the applicable procedures. The division of operational tasks should be clearly established.
12. Turning regulatory requirements into a dependable dealership process
Commission disclosure should be understood as part of the wider quality of the finance sales journey.
A dealership with clear customer communications, trained staff, accurate lender information and accessible records is better placed to identify weaknesses, respond to questions and demonstrate effective oversight.
For multi-site groups, the challenge is often consistency. A process that works at head office is of limited value if individual branches interpret it differently.
This is where appropriate systems and specialist support can make a practical difference.
ComplianceTrak works with UK automotive retailers through its appointed representative arrangements, compliance support and automotive-focused technology.
Its published Finance Tracker offering supports structured finance presentations, digital documentation, transaction records and management reporting. OnTrak supports staff training, while InsightTrak supports the identification and recording of customer vulnerability and related support.
These capabilities can help a dealership organise and evidence its processes. They do not replace the firm's legal responsibilities, professional judgement or the need to review actual customer outcomes.
Is your commission disclosure process ready for scrutiny?
If your dealership has not reviewed its commission disclosures, lender arrangements and finance sales controls since the Supreme Court judgment and the FCA's subsequent publications, now is an appropriate time to do so.
Speak to ComplianceTrak about a focused review of your dealership's finance sales governance, disclosure procedures and supporting evidence.
Whether your business is directly authorised or operates within an appointed representative arrangement, the objective is the same: clear customer information, effective management oversight and a defensible, proportionate process.
Regulatory sources and further reading
This article provides general regulatory information for automotive businesses. It is not a substitute for legal advice or an assessment of a firm's particular permissions, activities, contractual arrangements and circumstances. Regulatory developments described are current to the stated review date.
Comments